NuffNang

Friday, August 31, 2007

Merdeka Book Review

Ok folks, in the spirit of our Merdeka Golden Jubilee today, lets try something different today- ie. a book review.

I have just finished reading the book " The Reluctant Politician" - basically a biography of one of the least understood and a "could-have-been" 3rd PM of Malaysia if not for his untimely death in 1973: Tun Dr Ismail Abdul Rahman.

What attracted me are 2 things. One, why the lack of infomation on Dr Ismail from our pre-historic (no pun intended) text books? Yes, plenty of mention of TAR and his "Looking Back" and Tun Razak and his DEB/ NEP. But no credits of the then DPM of Malaysia from 1971-1973. Two, excerpts from this book mentioned his role in the aftermath of the May 13th 1969 - another pet interest of mine for the reason that it is also conveniently 'blanco-ed' from our official history.

The book started off in a shocking manner describing how the then Acting PM (since Tun Razak was away overseas) stumbled to his death after a heart attack at home, all alone. It then retraces his beginnings in Johor Bahru as a son of a local politician with 8 other siblings and 9 adopted Chinese sisters..

It then describes how he quit his 3rd year of medical school in Singapore after he refuses to give away his dance partner to his anatomy professor in a cabaret. He later lambasted the college as being " operated by a bunch of Gestapos" and continued a further 5 years of study in Melbourne. In between the serious stuff, more merry making ensued, ranging from simple countryside hiking to wine and women.

Upon returning to our shores and after a brief fling as a GP in JB, the lure of politics and the Merdeka spirit proved irresistible as he joined the government first as Malaya's 1st ambassador to the USA & UN and later as Minister of Internal Security & Minister of Home Affairs.

At the end of his tenure, the lasting impression I got is that he is like a version of the "Justice Pao' of 1960-70s Malaysian politics. According to his good childhood friend Robert Kuok (Malaysia's richest man now): " he is a man of strong character, high principles and great sense of fairness...probably the most non racial and non racist Malay I've ever met. Doc was a stickler of total fair play and correctness. Every Malay colleague fear him because of this, including Mahathir". People who ran afoul of the law irregardless, will feel the strong arm of the ISA- he even declared he will throw his own mother in jail if she did anything illegal ! His admirers range from LKY to TAR to Musa Hitam to Lim Kit Siang (though he did throw him into jail once) to our current PM.

All in all, a very good read. For history buffs like me it provided a good way to fill that little spot in our nation's history that up to now had remained empty. Personally, I think that Tun Ismail's role in our history was downplayed significantly not least because in his line of his duty, he had stepped on to many a people's shoes including getting a certain Dr M thrown out of the party.

So next up.. a book that has been banned in Malaysia: Alias Chin Peng- my side of history !


16 comments:

Szuefei said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
KG said...

Wow...good review Eric. Now that's another book in my to buy list. I guess they can't really give him prominence in the history books, cause that would make the other PMs look bad in comparison.

eric said...

Ok la folks..once in awhile must stimulate the good old brain cells. Btw KG, I did not really buy the book, just borrowed it from the Singapore library.
Haha, SF, I also did read nearly 80+% of all of Asterix books- my main 'supplier' during school days was Winston. Reli fahnie...I am not a fan of Tin Tin though.
Btw KG, when are you going away on your holiday and where?

eric said...

KG, I don't think its just a matter of making all the other PMs look bad but just the way and time when our SRP Sejarah textbooks were written- probably in the mid 70s.
Notice that after the Independence and Communist fight and the formation of Malaysia, subsequent events in the late 60s and early 70s were just neglected.
And for most of the folks reading this blog- "life" and our "memory" only started in the 80s, there is a huge infomation gap from the late 60s till early 80s to fill

Anonymous said...

Haha, my only contact with the book - seeing LKY in shorts in one of the photos ;-P

TH

AaahhH said...

Ooh.. since I have been reading up my entire library collection due to boredom.. this will be a good read!! Thanks for reviewing Eric.

And yes.. do read the Chin Peng book. Have u by any chance managed to watched the movie "Lelaki Komunis Terakhir"?

Szuefei said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Pang Khee Teik said...

The director of Lelaki Komunis Terakhir lent me a copy of the film and I threw a party at my place to watch it. A great Malaysian movie - and wonderfully unorthodox. This is my review of it: http://www.kakiseni.com/articles/reviews/MDkwMA.html

You can buy the DVD in Singapore. I know some pirated DVD sellers were hawking it back then. But I don't think they still have it. But my housemate has a copy and if you all are interested, we can throw another party to watch this. Haha.

eric said...

Good review there Khee Teik. I also agree with you that your granduncle's story is indeed very poignant and will make a good movie. What a tragic end.

I also like your last statement about knowing our nation's history and I guess that's what attracts us to the Chin Peng book and this Lelaki Komunis Terakhir movie. I haven't had the chance to watch it yet though. It's getting more and more difficult to get pirated DVDs in Sg nowadays-need to get the 'real' stuff from JB- even that, its playing russian roulette with the Sg customs especially if travel by land/bus and not car.

Pang Khee Teik said...

Hey Eric

Thanks for reading my long review!

Oh, Lelaki Komunis Terakhir is available at HMV the last time I checked. It's legal in Singapore.

Actually, you all should check out the blog of the director Amir Muhammad.

http://lastcommunist.blogspot.com/

http://amirmu.blogspot.com/

By the way, talking about banned things, tomorrow (Sunday) at The Annexe, Central Market, some NGOs have a celebration of Freedom of Expression. There will be performances of banned stuffs, political cartoons exhibition, workshop on hidden information and official secrets, singer songwriters on the city.

I am organising a session called Malaysians Have Sex (shocking!), in which straight and queer personalities talk about their sexual awakenings. It's 4pm in one of the galleries.

For more info, www.50-44.org. Or call me: 012 305 1135

KG said...

OK, I would leave you guys and gals to work out your communist/sex sessions. We now have enough contributors so don't dissapoint me when I check back here in 2 weeks time ok?

Till then, take care peps and.....yes, go ahead, do something naughty ;)

eric said...

Ok, have fun where ever u are, KG. I will try n post at least 1 not so boring subject soon...time permitting.. haha.

Thanks. Khee Teik. I will try go check out HMV for your recommendation.

Anonymous said...

Have a good holiday KG! Don't forget to take pics of the bikini clad women by the beach and post it here!

OSW

eric said...

Hmmm.. u do seem to be online in the blog quite often nowadays mr OSW. much more than the missus at least. What about posting something here? or start your own blog (like you mentioned before)?

Szuefei said...

more than the missus?! are you sure?

eric said...

Got la..at least for comments linked to this thread. Before your reply, the official score for the number of replies here is:
OSW 1 : The Missus 0

(ok, at least until someone solves the mystery of some missing posts)